2010s
2018-19
- Super 8BC High2-1 over Pope Francis
2017-18
- Super 8BC High2-1 over Pope Francis
2016-17
- Super 8Arlington2-1 over Central Catholic
2015-16
- Super 8Malden Catholic2-1 over St Johns Prep
2014-15
- Super 8St Johns Prep2-1 over Malden Catholic
2013-14
- Super 8Malden Catholic5-3 over Austin Prep
2012-13
- Super 8Malden Catholic3-2 over Austin Prep
2011-12
- Super 8Malden Catholic3-1 over BC High
2010-11
- Super 8Malden Catholic4-3 over St Johns Prep
2009-10
- Super 8Hingham1-0 over Catholic Memorial
2000s
2008-09
- Super 8Catholic Memorial5-1 over Burlington
2007-08
- Super 8Reading3-0 over Malden Catholic
2005-06
- Super 8BC High2-1 over Catholic Memorial
2004-05
- Super 8Catholic Memorial3-1 over Arlington Catholic
2003-04
- Super 8Catholic Memorial3-1 over BC High
2002-03
- Super 8Catholic Memorial3-2 over BC High
2001-02
- Super 8B.C. High2-0 over Catholic Memorial
2000-01
- Super 8Catholic Memorial1-0 (OT) over BC High
1999-00
- Super 8Catholic Memorial6-3 over BC High
1990s
1998-99
- Super 8Catholic Memorial5-2 over BC High
1997-98
- Super 8Catholic Memorial5-1 over Archbishop Williams
1996-97
- Super 8Arlington Catholic5-4 over BC High
1994-95
- Super 8Catholic Memorial3-1 over BC High
1993-94
- Super 8Catholic Memorial5-1 over Arlington Catholic
1992-93
- Super 8Catholic Memorial5-2 over Medford
1991-92
- Super 8Catholic Memorial3-1 over Matignon
1990-91
- Super 8Catholic Memorial5-2 over BC High
Champions through 2018-19 come from the MassHSHockey record book; later years from the MIAA's champions list and tournament results. Final scores are shown where the final is on record.
